HEXACO vs Big Five: Understanding the Six-Factor vs Five-Factor Models

When exploring personality psychology, two models stand out as the most scientifically rigorous and widely researched: the HEXACO model and the Big Five model (also known as the Five-Factor Model or OCEAN). Both frameworks have revolutionized our understanding of human personality, but they take different approaches to categorizing the fundamental dimensions of personality.

If you're trying to decide which personality test to take or which model better represents human personality, this comprehensive comparison will help you understand the key differences, strengths, and applications of each approach.

What is the Big Five (OCEAN) Model?

The Big Five personality model emerged from decades of statistical research analyzing personality descriptors in human language. First developed in the 1960s and refined through the 1980s and 1990s, it identifies five broad dimensions of personality:

The Five Factors (OCEAN):

1. Openness to Experience

• Intellectual curiosity, creativity, appreciation for art and beauty
• Range: Conventional and traditional vs. imaginative and open-minded

2. Conscientiousness

• Organization, discipline, goal-directed behavior, self-control
• Range: Disorganized and careless vs. disciplined and reliable

3. Extraversion

• Sociability, assertiveness, positive emotionality, energy level
• Range: Introverted and reserved vs. outgoing and energetic

4. Agreeableness

• Compassion, trust, cooperation, tendency to be prosocial
• Range: Competitive and skeptical vs. trusting and cooperative

5. Neuroticism

• Emotional stability, stress reactivity, tendency toward negative emotions
• Range: Emotionally stable vs. anxious and emotionally reactive

What is the HEXACO Model?

The HEXACO model was developed in the 2000s by psychologists Kibeom Lee and Michael Ashton as an alternative to the Big Five. Through cross-cultural research and re-analysis of personality data, they identified six major dimensions of personality:

The Six Factors (HEXACO):

1. Honesty-Humility (H)

• Sincerity, fairness, greed avoidance, modesty
• Range: Manipulative and self-serving vs. honest and humble

2. Emotionality (E)

• Emotional reactivity, anxiety, dependence, sentimentality
• Range: Emotionally stable vs. emotionally reactive (similar to reversed Neuroticism)

3. eXtraversion (X)

• Social boldness, sociability, liveliness, positive emotions
• Range: Introverted vs. extraverted (similar to Big Five Extraversion)

4. Agreeableness (A)

• Patience, tolerance, peacefulness, lenience
• Range: Quarrelsome vs. agreeable (narrower than Big Five Agreeableness)

5. Conscientiousness (C)

• Organization, diligence, perfectionism, prudence
• Range: Lazy and careless vs. organized and disciplined (similar to Big Five)

6. Openness to Experience (O)

• Aesthetic appreciation, inquisitiveness, creativity, unconventionality
• Range: Conventional vs. creative (similar to Big Five Openness)

Key Differences Between HEXACO and Big Five

1. Number of Factors

Big Five: Five dimensions HEXACO: Six dimensions

The most obvious difference is that HEXACO includes an additional factor—Honesty-Humility—that doesn't appear in the Big Five model.

2. The Honesty-Humility Factor

This is HEXACO's most distinctive contribution to personality psychology. The Honesty-Humility dimension captures traits related to:

• Sincerity: Being genuine vs. manipulative
• Fairness: Avoiding cheating and corruption
• Greed Avoidance: Not being motivated by material gain
• Modesty: Humility vs. narcissistic tendencies

Research shows this dimension is particularly important for predicting:

• Ethical behavior in workplace settings
• Likelihood to engage in counterproductive work behaviors
• Risk of white-collar crime and dishonesty
• Leadership effectiveness and trustworthiness

3. Redefined Agreeableness

In the Big Five, Agreeableness is quite broad, encompassing both:

• Compassionate, caring behavior (captured in HEXACO's Emotionality)
• Cooperative, non-aggressive behavior (captured in HEXACO's Agreeableness)

HEXACO separates these concepts:

• HEXACO Agreeableness focuses more narrowly on patience, tolerance, and cooperation
• HEXACO Emotionality includes the empathy and caring aspects

4. Cross-Cultural Validity

HEXACO was specifically developed using cross-cultural data from multiple languages and cultures, making it potentially more universally applicable than the Big Five, which was primarily developed using English-language personality descriptors.

Big Five has been validated across many cultures but was initially developed within Western, English-speaking contexts.

Scientific Research and Validation

Big Five Research Foundation

The Big Five model has:

• 40+ years of research supporting its validity
• Thousands of studies across multiple disciplines
• Extensive meta-analyses confirming its cross-cultural applicability
• Widespread acceptance in academic and applied psychology

Key research findings:

• Predicts job performance across occupations
• Stable across the adult lifespan
• Heritable traits with genetic components
• Predictive of mental health outcomes

HEXACO Research Foundation

The HEXACO model has:

• 20+ years of research since its development in 2000
• Growing body of evidence supporting its six-factor structure
• Cross-cultural validation across dozens of languages
• Unique predictive validity for ethical and interpersonal behaviors

Key research findings:

• Better prediction of ethical behavior and integrity
• Stronger cross-cultural factor structure
• Improved prediction of workplace deviance
• Enhanced understanding of personality-behavior relationships

Practical Applications: Which Should You Use?

Choose Big Five When:

1. Career Assessment

• Most career-related research uses Big Five dimensions
• Widely accepted in HR and organizational psychology
• Extensive job performance prediction data available

2. Mental Health Context

• Strong research linking Big Five to psychological disorders
• Clinical psychology primarily uses Five-Factor Model
• Therapeutic interventions often reference Big Five dimensions

3. Academic Research

• Comparing with existing literature (most uses Big Five)
• Longitudinal studies and life outcome predictions
• Personality development research

4. General Personality Understanding

• Well-established and easily interpretable framework
• Abundant resources for understanding results
• Widely recognized by psychologists and the public

Choose HEXACO When:

1. Ethical and Integrity Assessment

• Hiring for positions requiring high integrity
• Assessing risk of counterproductive work behaviors
• Understanding moral and ethical decision-making

2. Cross-Cultural Contexts

• Working across different cultures and languages
• Need for culturally universal personality framework
• International research or applications

3. Interpersonal and Leadership Assessment

• Understanding trustworthiness and leadership potential
• Predicting team dynamics and cooperation
• Assessing prosocial and antisocial tendencies

4. Comprehensive Personality Profiling

• Want the most complete picture of personality
• Interested in honesty and humility dimensions
• Research on personality and social behavior

Strengths and Limitations

Big Five Strengths:

• Extensive research base with robust validation
• Widely accepted in academic and professional contexts
• Well-developed assessment tools with strong psychometric properties
• Clear practical applications in career and clinical psychology

Big Five Limitations:

• Missing honesty/integrity dimension that HEXACO captures
• Broad agreeableness factor that may conflate different traits
• Western-centric development potentially limiting cross-cultural applicability

HEXACO Strengths:

• Comprehensive six-factor structure capturing additional personality variance
• Strong cross-cultural validity from multinational development
• Unique predictive power for ethical and interpersonal behaviors
• Refined factor definitions improving conceptual clarity

HEXACO Limitations:

• Newer model with less extensive research base
• Lower recognition among practitioners and the general public
• Fewer assessment tools and interpretation resources available

Test-Taking Experience Comparison

Big Five Tests Typically Feature:

• 60-240 questions depending on version
• Likert scale ratings (1-5 or 1-7)
• 15-30 minutes completion time
• Results showing percentile scores on five dimensions

HEXACO Tests Typically Feature:

• 60-200 questions in standard versions
• Similar rating scale format
• 15-25 minutes completion time
• Results showing scores on six dimensions plus subfacets

Both models offer free online assessments with reliable psychometric properties, making them accessible for personal development and research purposes.

Research-Based Recommendations

For Individual Self-Discovery:

Take both tests if you want the most comprehensive personality profile. The Big Five provides the foundational understanding that most personality research builds upon, while HEXACO adds the crucial honesty-humility dimension that reveals important aspects of your character and interpersonal style.

For Professional Development:

Start with Big Five for career-related insights, as most occupational research uses this model. Consider HEXACO additionally if your role involves significant ethical responsibilities or cross-cultural interactions.

For Research Purposes:

Choose based on your research questions:

• Big Five for replicating existing studies or connecting to the broader literature
• HEXACO for investigating ethical behavior, cross-cultural personality, or when you want the most comprehensive personality model

Conclusion: Complementary Rather Than Competing

Rather than viewing HEXACO and Big Five as competing models, they're better understood as complementary approaches to personality psychology. The Big Five provides the foundational framework that decades of research have built upon, while HEXACO extends and refines this foundation with important additions.

Key Takeaways:

1. Big Five remains the gold standard for general personality assessment with unmatched research validation
2. HEXACO offers valuable additions, particularly the honesty-humility dimension crucial for understanding ethical behavior
3. Both models are scientifically rigorous and provide reliable personality insights
4. Your choice should depend on your specific needs: career assessment (Big Five), ethical evaluation (HEXACO), or comprehensive profiling (both)

For the most complete understanding of personality, consider exploring both frameworks. Each offers unique insights that together provide a richer, more nuanced view of human personality than either model alone.

Take the Big Five Test | Take the HEXACO Test | Compare All Personality Tests